The Digital Euro: An Investment in the Future or a Risk for Citizens?

Sonja Stojadinovic

Politics

16.11.26

Прегледи

Brussels presents it as a shield against American dominance in payments and as cash for the digital age. Critics see something else: power concentrated in an institution that answers to no voter, with no real counterweight, and a system whose design the ECB decides alone, even though that is far from a purely technical question.

The digital euro is one of the most ambitious projects the European Central Bank (ECB) has undertaken in recent years, a new form of public money in digital form. It would be an electronic form of cash, issued directly by the ECB and existing alongside banknotes and coins. The project is close to launch: a pilot is expected by mid-2027, building the entire system is estimated to cost €1.3 billion, and maintaining it €320 million. Before it has even gone live, it has already divided experts, politicians and citizens across the European Union.

Unlike money held in commercial banks, the digital euro would be a direct claim on the central bank – just like physical cash. But Europe has not welcomed it with open arms. Questions have been raised about the privacy of transactions, how far the state may restrict payments, and how much responsibility the ECB would bear if the system were hacked or something else went wrong.

What Is the Digital Euro, and Why Does the ECB Want It?

The digital euro is designed as an additional payment option that would let citizens and businesses in the eurozone pay electronically with public money issued by the central bank. According to the European Parliament, it would be “a new electronic form of cash” that could be used in shops, online and for transfers between individuals. The key difference lies in the issuer: money in bank accounts is commercial bank money, whereas the digital euro would be issued directly by the ECB.

The ECB has several key reasons for introducing it. First, it would strengthen Europe’s strategic autonomy in payments. The eurozone today depends heavily on international card schemes, above all the American networks Visa and Mastercard. Just how risky that dependence is became clear in August 2025, when US sanctions against French judge Nicolas Guillou, an International Criminal Court judge who took part in issuing the arrest warrant for Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu, cut him off from his own money. A digital euro, issued and run within the EU, would protect citizens from scenarios like this.

Second, the digital euro would fill a gap in the EU’s digital economy by letting people use cash online, something physical banknotes cannot do. Third, according to the European Parliament, businesses would pay lower fees than they do for card payments, because fee levels would be set within the EU.

The Digital Euro: An Investment in the Future or a Risk for Citizens?Source: Envato

The Advantages of the Digital Euro

One of the strongest arguments in favour of the digital euro is that it would reinforce Europe’s sovereignty over its payment system. As the European Parliament notes, most eurozone countries rely heavily on international card schemes, which means that cashless payments – along with the associated personal data and fees – are processed outside the EU. The digital euro would create a pan-European payment infrastructure, independent of outside players.

The second major argument is privacy. According to the European Parliament, the system is designed so that the ECB could not directly link individual payments to specific users. For offline payments, only the payer and the payee would know the transaction details, a level of privacy very close to that of cash. This matters because, as the German consultancy Senacor points out, many private tech companies already have far deeper insight into consumer spending habits than the ECB would have under the digital euro framework.

Nor would the digital euro replace cash. The European Parliament states clearly that eurozone countries would be legally obliged to keep physical cash available, and citizens would remain free to choose how they pay. The digital euro is neither a cryptocurrency nor an investment: its value is fixed 1:1 to the euro, and it pays no interest.

Senacor also debunks the myth of bank runs: current designs provide for a cap on how much an individual can hold and pay no interest, precisely to prevent potential banking crises.

Disadvantages and Risks

Despite these advantages, critics voice serious concerns. Privacy First, a Dutch privacy organisation, warns that Europe is sleepwalking into a system without democratic legitimacy. It points to several key problems: the concentration of power in the ECB, which is not democratically accountable; the lack of a genuine counterweight; and the fact that the ECB alone decides on the system’s design, even though this is not merely a technical matter.

One of the biggest fears is programmable money – money that can only be spent on certain things. Privacy First also warns of indirect compulsion: a government could, for example, pay out subsidies exclusively in digital euros, or require certain goods and services to be bought only with them. There is also a risk that cash – the only form of money that offers genuine anonymity – will gradually be squeezed out, and that states will turn the digital euro from an option into an obligation. That would give them far greater control over how and where citizens spend their money.

Privacy First also raises the question of liability: the ECB states that it will accept no liability for errors or fraud in digital euro transactions, which runs contrary to the European treaties. Users could be left without legal protection precisely when they need it most.

Critics point out that in 2022, when the European Commission held a public consultation on the digital euro, more than 19,500 citizens responded, and not a single response was positive. That points to a deep gap between the institutions and citizens.

It is important to understand that the ECB is set up as an independent institution that member states cannot influence politically. At the same time, it bears minimal liability under EU law should the digital euro collapse. First, the European Court of Justice sets high thresholds before the ECB can be held liable: EU institutions such as the ECB are liable for damage only where there has been a “sufficiently serious breach” of a rule of EU law.

Second, damages can only be claimed before the European Court, a high and costly hurdle for ordinary citizens, and cases there routinely take two to three years. The database of legal proceedings brought against the ECB contains not a single case in which the claimants won on the grounds of a breach of EU law.

Control Over Citizens’ Money, Packaged as Monetary Independence

The digital euro is a complex project with potentially far-reaching consequences for the European economy and for citizens’ everyday lives. On the one hand, it offers stronger European sovereignty, less dependence on foreign payment systems, more privacy than commercial alternatives, and an additional payment option that does not threaten cash. On the other, there are serious concerns about the concentration of power in the ECB, the lack of democratic oversight, privacy risks, programmable money and unclear liability for errors. As Privacy First stresses, a broad democratic debate is needed to ensure that the digital euro is not introduced without a thorough examination of all the risks and alternatives.

And the risks are real. Without the internet there is no digital euro – and with the digital euro comes state control over where and how citizens spend their money. An alternative exists: cash. Yet cash is precisely what is being pushed out, most often under the pretext of fighting money laundering. If citizens are to remain financially free, both must exist.

Sonja Stojadinovic

Sonja Stojadinović graduated in political science from the Faculty of Law "Justinianus Primus" in Skopje, where she received her master's degree in International Politics on the topic "Nonviolent Struggle in Politics: Factors for Success and Failure". She later advanced her education at the University of Graz with a master's thesis on the topic: "Political and Financial Conditions for Loans from Chinese and EU Banks for Infrastructure Investments in the Balkans". She works as a freelance author for the Croatian portal Lupiga and is an external collaborator of the Blue Europe Institute in Luxembourg.